The United Presbyterian Church of Wurtemburg was organized in 1859 by Rev. Thomas Guthrie, D. P., who served the church until 1867. The members of the new church originally belonged to the Reformed Presbyterian Church of Perry Township until splitting. The Reformed Presbyterian Church of Perry Township traces its roots back to the old Camp Run Reformed Church formed sometime before 1825. The old Camp Run Reformed Church originally was located on Samuel McElwains farm, over the hill from Pleasant Hill Grange Hall with Thomas C. Guthrie serving as pastor. In 1833, a group split from the church and the new movement became the Pleasant Hill Church. In 1840, the church built a new building on Harvey McElwains farm. The original Camp Run Reformed Church ceased to exist by 1851.
The Wurtemburg large frame building was built in 1860 upon land donated by James Mehard, a member of the congregation, to house the original eighty members and a Sunday-School that has been kept up most of the time since. 1861 marked the year Pleasant Hill & Wurtemburg congregations united to form the United Presbyterian Church of Wurtemburg. The first regular pastor of the new organization was Rev. J. H. Peacock, who came about 1867 and preached here for five years. Rev. John P. Glenn took over the duties November 1, 1874, at the same time supplying the Center Church in Shenango Township.
A portion of the congregation, some forty-five members, left the church in 1873, and formed a new congregation in Perry Township called Camp Run. They built a church in 1874 and held meetings in connection with the Mountville United Presbyterian Church.
Sunday June 2, 1985 the Wurtemburg Presbyterian Church marked it’s 125th Anniversary by opening the church’s time capsule from September 1948. The contents of the capsule contained a church bulletin from 1948, a complete listing of the membership and a history of the church 1922-1948. The time capsule was put back into the cornerstone along with mementos from the 125th celebration.
If you got a little confused reading the history of the churches above don’t worry, I got a little confused writing it. This is a very old church that has continued to grow, split, and evolve over the years and we would love to hear your memories of the church. If you would like to share you memories of the church or its members, please leave a comment below or email us by CLICKING HERE.